Dividing "American Idol" judges into two "teams" was Fox's first acknowledgment it has one judge too many. Who has to go?
-
Randy: His bag o' catch phrases seems sad and irrelevant these days, over in the far left corner.
25%
-
Kara: Supposed "industry insider" and is little more than another fangirl.
51%
-
Paula: Her semi-lucid rants/poetry/fortune cookie advice aren't as funny when they make sense.
19%
-
Simon: His boredom is obvious.
4%
Created on Apr 17, 2009
Closed
Total Votes: 998
