• 10 - EPIC! One of the best finales ever! It’s a whole new show now. Jeremy Carver rules.
  55%
• 9 - I’m still weeping over that Sam and Dean scene in the church. Crowley too...just wow.
  29%
• 8 - Trying to figure out all that happened. My mind is blown.
  4%
• 7 - There were a few inconsistencies, but that ending killed me.
  5%
• 6 - Overall good, but too choppy for my taste.
  1%
• 5 - What in the world did they do to Castiel? This isn’t sitting right with me.
  0%
• 4 - Underwhelmed. This could have gone in a better direction.
  1%
• 3 - Wrong, wrong, wrong. Only one scene made this worth it.
  0%
• 2 - Blasphemy! What did Carver do to my show?
  0%
• 1 - Worst...finale...ever
  0%

Closed

Total Votes: 855

• 10 - Perfect in every way. The finale is going to kill me!
  24%
• 9 - Wonderful. So shocking, emotional, and very exciting.
  24%
• 8 - Great. A little rough in parts, but good setup for next week.
  29%
• 7 - Good, but the pacing was off. Not perfect by any means.
  6%
• 6 - Average. I expected more for a finale setup.
  8%
• 5 - Disappointed. This could have been so much better.
  3%
• 4 - Weak. After two great episodes, we’re back to this? Ugh.
  1%
• 3 - Below average. Another glaring example of missed opportunities.
  0%
• 2 - Bad. There was so much wrong, I’m primal screaming.
  1%
• 1 - A total waste. Thanks show for taking 42 precious minutes of my life.
  0%

Closed

Total Votes: 432

• 10– I’m an exhausted, excited, weepy, laughing, squeeing, jittery mess! All hail Edlund!
  51%
• 9– The care put into continuity, pacing and epic storytelling makes me one extremely happy fan.
  18%
• 8– Amazing. The acting was the best yet this season. Sam got a great story!
  12%
• 7– I was slightly confused in parts, but overall I’m super pleased with what we learned.
  4%
• 6– I found the plotting to be a bit sloppy, but I’m still excited about other parts.
  1%
• 5– Average. Too much going on with Castiel, Naomi, Crowley, etc. The brotherly moments won me.
  2%
• 4– I didn’t like it. Something just didn’t come together for me.
  6%
• 3– The episode was weak. I expected better.
  1%
• 2– I’m so disappointed. This is the direction Carver wants to go with things?
  2%
• 1– I’ll never watch this one again.
  0%

Closed

Total Votes: 388

• 10– It had everything! Laughs, hugs, tears, continuity, bed head...Robbie Thompson, you so know us.
  67%
• 9 – Felicia Day and Carver Edlund FTW! Plus Dean in uniform? (thud)
  13%
• 8 – Dean, Charlie and Sam make the perfect team, don’t they? Love how they watch out for each other
  10%
• 7 – Such a vast improvement over last episode. Not perfect, but very enjoyable.
  4%
• 6 – I liked, but something didn’t quite connect with me.
  1%
• 5 – Average standalone fare. Next week looks amazing!
  1%
• 4 – The video game concept just pushed me too far. The hugs were cool though.
  0%
• 3 – I can’t take these filler episodes. Onto the trials!
  0%
• 2 – Sorry, but Charlie grates on my nerves. Focus on the brothers.
  0%
• 1 – I just give up.
  0%

Closed

Total Votes: 416

• 10 - A vital, mind-blowing mytharc classic! I’ll be watching this repeatedly.
  19%
• 9 - An intense, chair gripping, yet emotional hour of television.
  17%
• 8 - A couple plot holes, but overall great, especially the acting and directing.
  25%
• 7 - More than a few glaring plot holes, but I loved seeing Bobby again!
  9%
• 6 - Boring, predictable, and very generic in plotting. Had a couple of worthy moments.
  1%
• 5 - Why couldn’t this have been a two parter? Too much was crammed in one episode.
  6%
• 4 - Nice to see Crowley’s search for Purgatory in all of S6 be invalidated in one ep.
  1%
• 3 - Plot holes so wide the Impala could drive through them. Fans are smarter than that.
  12%
• 2 - Can these writers never do another script for Supernatural. Please??
  3%
• 1 - That was just an overall insult to my intelligence and loyalty as a fan.
  2%

Closed

Total Votes: 446

• 10 – Awesome standalone, the best of the season!
  4%
• 9 – I love they were able to find a way for Krissy to come back.
  14%
• 8 – Great MOTW case. I liked the young hunters, but didn’t love.
  14%
• 7 – Not the greatest story done, but I enjoyed it overall.
  24%
• 6 – I don’t know, it had it’s moments, but something was missing.
  12%
• 5 – At least the boys looked pretty this week.
  9%
• 4 – What sort of an evil plan was that? Weak, weak plotting.
  5%
• 3 – Listless, dull, and a story that didn’t make much sense.
  7%
• 2 – This writer doesn’t get Sam and Dean at all.
  1%
• 1 – Completely useless filler.
  4%

Closed

Total Votes: 385

• 10 – Oh my! I laughed, I cried, I…damn, I’m still a total nervous wreck.
  44%
• 9 – What an amazing hour. So sad about Meg, but I’m so thrilled with the rest.
  31%
• 8 – Megstiel, Destiel, Meg/Sam, Crowley/Naomi - I’m in shipper Heaven!
  2%
• 7 – It moved the plot bunny along, so I’m happy.
  7%
• 6 – Good, but I’m too confused over the Crowley continuity.
  2%
• 5 – Didn’t do much for me, but I didn’t hate it.
  4%
• 4 – Underwhelmed.
  2%
• 3 – I don’t like where any of this is going. It’s depressing.
  0%
• 2 – All I saw was a poor ripoff of “Swan Song.”
  3%
• 1 – What an epic failure.
  0%

Closed

Total Votes: 473

• 10 – Incredible! A win all around.
  15%
• 9 – Love the parallel between the God story and the boys.
  19%
• 8 – Sam and Dean are just killing me with their pain! (In a good way)
  22%
• 7 – The God story was a bit clunky, but the brotherly moments were perfect.
  24%
• 6 – At least it was better than last week.
  8%
• 5 – A half hearted effort at real drama.
  1%
• 4 – I fell asleep halfway through. Another snoozer.
  0%
• 3 – They’re going into the break with this weak episode?
  4%
• 2 –Complete blashphemy to Greek mythology.
  0%
• 1 – Another unmitigated disaster. Way to go show.
  0%

Closed

Total Votes: 459